the ironies of becoming a white male have not escaped me although I am not entirely sure that this is what I have become so much as “male” describes the position where most people see me standing now. so many presumptions. I await my six-figure salary and will probably still be waiting next time we speak. expectations do not change so easily and neither do notions of entitlement no matter what they tell you it is not suddenly a free ride. that it were. that I had some idea of how to garner considerations and at the same time feel that they were my due. it still surprises me to be looked in the eye but at the same time it pisses me off that they didn’t used to. as though it were not me then or it is not me anymore. of course this is entirely possible but that is not the point.
I am neither alone nor in great company in saying I was once a girl or that is I thought I was a girl or I forgot that I had thought I was a boy for long enough that I sighed resigned to answer to girl for what looked to be the rest of my life until many years later when suddenly it was clear I did not have to do that anymore but and this is a subject that deserves a look in far greater complexity than I can give it in a reasonable number of words so it may be that the best way to put the question is to put it into questions. may it be for instance that a sense of personal infallibility and the birthright expectation that the world bow to one’s whims is a scaffold holding up bodies raged through with chemical stimuli to impulsiveness. but the structure itself would have taken a lifetime by which I mean between birth and something like adolescence or young adulthood that first lifetime that takes nearly all one’s life and then the race to the grave that first lifetime it would have taken to construct carefully any belief in my own perfect impenetrable authority nor was it delivered as a piece with the vial of testosterone that started my middle-aged puberty and its eventual effects the ones that have largely determined how the world will hail me and whether they will give credence to what I say those effects hardly extend to my longstanding and deeply impressed sense of my own chronic weakness and fallibility. that is the world hails a name to which I cannot answer if the answer they expect is one that assumes its own authority.
which also given that I write this at all may be ironic in its own way but writing has survived authority for quite some time by now. what you see written here is neither the truth nor a lie and in writing I do not mean to claim a position from which I could make out the essential difference between truth and falsehood regarding what has happened to the person called me. which is to say that memory even when it is not about something made up is still something made up about what is remembered. what has happened persists as a point around which memory orbits without the benefit of being able to look directly into that point as though it were bright as the sun without even the shield of our planet’s atmosphere so full of light that one cannot look at it without damaging one’s ability to see. if the sun is the furnace from which everything else will eventually emerge unable to recall its own origins a lake of fire at birth rather than death then perhaps the moment of trauma’s amnesia is also something like a fountain of sparks: a blindingly obscure source of potential material raw and naked awaiting a wardrobe it can only retrieve from within itself or by borrowing from its nursery-mates. and then you see do you not how we are related but not identical. you and me and anything upon which you can lay your finger.
but the idea that women can become men is ludicrous. by that I mean that it is an idea held as ludicrous as a corollary to essentialist notions of anatomically-determined gender. the idea that men can become women is terrifying and rage-worthy but that a woman might become a man is simply a laugh and hardly worth the speculation as to how it might be achieved. of course there is no way to penetrate the stronghold of tightly held sphincters of present-day American masculinity or that is most of the people around me who have ever given it a second thought never give it a second thought. oh you mean you are really a girl. wow you certainly look the part. you are a master of disguise. I never would have guessed. you pass completely.
not that I haven’t been humored and cajoled by the more obviously well-meaning and not that the general anonymous public when confronted with just me wearing everyday clothes is any the wiser. they expect me to think I am right when I do not and cannot having listened quietly to the many ways in which I was not to be allowed into the hall of authorial will and perhaps this is just me but whatever authority I am granted in a given situation disintegrates upon receiving the slightest push into a series of increasingly panicked interjections issuing from a kind of free-fall that can never be anticipated properly. without some tangible indication from another party that I know what I am talking about I have no clear idea as to whether I do or not and that is why in general I soft-pedal argument until I have simply had enough and must walk away. or if with a trusted friend I will break out into some hyst-/testerical rant spewing fifty-cent words this way and that because they are all that protect me from being torn to pieces.
which happens anyway.
the mystery of entitlement or that it is a mystery ensures that I will hold my tongue in most face-to-face conversations with men for whom entitlement does not appear to be any sort of mystery at all. how it must feel to believe that one is simply right and that one should simply be listened to! it may be true that I could open my mouth and be greeted with silence from others but having been a girl at thirteen fourteen or so and especially having already been a violated girl by age eleven I learned to take my cue from the exigencies of self-preservation which generally dictated that I say nothing and furthermore that I cast a withering eye at any emergent self-confidence with which, say, education might be providing me or experience might be teaching me if I were allowed to trust my own experience.
which I was not. like most children of the sixties and seventies I was told what I was allowed to feel as well as what was the right way to think about anything.
this is one story among tens of thousands if not millions and you will get a different one from whomever you ask for one. this was not what I meant and here is not where I expected to have arrived or rather although I was aware that arriving was neither a possibility nor a desirable goal I was not prepared to pass through where I have passed through those times I have passed through where I have passed through. there is no clean transition or that is I have not experienced one. the sequelae of emerging queer and bleeding-hearted in the thick of Southern Baptist rituals of mythopoetic abuse persist with or without an ambiguously-gendered appearance and with or without constant social reinforcement.
condescension feels pretty much the same as it always did although I have lost somewhat the ability to swallow my rage whole and entire and for years on end but this is not so much a consequence of changing gender presentation as of meticulously excavating and decommissioning a vast backlog of psychological defenses which has left me arguably healthier but evidently more brittle.
laying this all out here seems foolhardy but at the same time unavoidable and necessary and futile and without remedy. as though I pick up a broken pencil and a torn sheet of waxed paper having in mind to design a storm-proof, earthquake-proof, termite-proof, rust-proof architectural miracle. but the means they are not inadequate they are completely out of hand even as I try to grasp them.
on the other hand I can state fairly confidently that it is better not to be stared down by middle america when standing in line for the bathroom than it is to be scrutinized for signs of bodily protrusion by people whose worst fears may be standing next to someone like me in a place where we all have to compromise our safety in order to relieve ourselves of the various wastes of metabolism and respiration. The whole restroom ordeal is the focal point of an as-yet unheard stress and and unmitigated pain in the lives of the not strictly gendered and there was a time in my life when I found middle to aging ladies the most intimidating persons to have to deal with while trying to get to a place to pee.
men on the other hand will do anything possible not to look at you as you make your way into a stall so no one in the men’s room even knows what you look like much less cares although I have to ask you this and that is why is there a glory hole in the stall at school. We’re talking several flights of stairs to get to academic offices tucked into a corner of the building so it is not as though men looking for anonymous blowjobs roam the hallways there in large numbers.
or maybe they do. maybe I don’t know the men in my department very well.
I did not recognize the glory hole for what it was when I first saw it as it was my very first glory hole and after a lifetime of hearing the glory hole mythologized I never, I suppose, expected actually to run into one. of course this inability to recognize the glory hole was only exacerbated by the fact that for thirty-five years I only went into women’s rooms where you will find no glory holes and indeed very little acknowledgement of the tacit sexuality of the public restroom. that and in this particular men’s room people had been poking pen-sized holes through the plastic stall wall for some time which holes I supposed were for catching furtive glimpses so when a hole two and a half inches in diameter appeared my first thought was man. they must really want to see.
it dawned upon me at length.
which realization was helped along having noticing certain spatters which would have otherwise had to come from say a squirt gun although I suppose in a way they did. I thought you all used tissue or towels.
you wonder don’t you why they would build men’s stalls with easily perforated polymer given the myth of the glory hole a myth so widespread that denizens of women’s rooms know all about their function–if not their appearance–years before ever seeing one. interestingly this glory hole is perfectly, smoothly circular. is there a specialized tool for this or do humanities students at Berkeley carry cordless drills in their book bags?
the glory hole complicates considerably my efforts to pee unnoticed. at least once a day though someone stuffs toilet paper into it but oddly before the end of that day the wad of paper will be removed which makes me wonder just when the thing gets used. in any case I for some reason do not want to be the killjoy who blocks the hole so instead I do all I can not to be exposed before anyone who might be in the next stall. because regardless of its intended purpose, the glory hole is large enough to reveal to anyone looking pretty much anything they might be looking for.
and so it goes. when I was a small child I thought that grown-ups knew what they were doing and had complete control over and confidence in those great details I imagined they seriously and soberly concerned themselves with. it is not precisely that I expected to be handed an owner’s manual but I did think that life’s educating effects would have the effect of educating me about anything I would need to know when the time came to deploy that knowledge in the service of living life well.
today I do not know anyone who is not absolutely confused. people younger than I am, people older than I am: all completely confused. There are some who handle that confusion more gracefully or artfully than others and there are some who consign it to a sealed and padlocked chamber buried deeply underneath such an overly-optimistic mythopoiesis that it posits clear rules and clear penalties for breaking those rules but the confusion remains. occasionally it shifts position and all the clarity of centuries of revelation is shaken violently to the point where frantic prayers and petitions are unleashed in such volume that the words themselves form enough of a pattern that anyone who needs to see a concrete structure at work in the cosmos can easily project one through the interstices.